
Leftover chicken, black bean & chipotle bowl
65g protein
510 kcal10 min
Every macro tracker answers one question before it answers any other: who sets your targets, and who changes them when the scale stops moving. Two of these six decide and keep deciding, two decide once, and two never decide at all. Price, database and paywall follow from that.
Tracker comparisons usually rank features, which is why they all read the same and none of them help. Every app here logs food against a daily number. What separates them is where that number comes from and what happens to it in week three, when your weight has moved and the figure you were given at signup is no longer the right one.
There are only three answers to that, and six apps split evenly between them.
MacroFactor and Carbon both watch what you log against what the scale does, work out what you are really burning, and hand you a new target. You are paying for the algorithm, which is why neither has a free tier: the adjusting is the product.
Both share a flaw worth knowing before you pay: the estimate needs two to four weeks of honest, unbroken logging before it settles. They are at their least useful exactly when you are newest and most likely to quit, and MacroFactor's trial is over long before that.
MyFitnessPal and Lose It! work your target out once, from a formula, and then wait for you to notice it is wrong. That is not as bad as it sounds — if you already have numbers from a coach, a dietitian or your own spreadsheet, an app that keeps proposing its own is just something else to override.
Cronometer and MacrosFirst take the position that your targets are your business. Neither will calculate a deficit for you or nudge you when the scale stalls; both are better than the other four at the thing they do instead. Cronometer is a nutrition database with a tracker attached — 82 micronutrients, from lab-analysed sources — and MacrosFirst works portions back from a goal you have already decided.
| App | Who sets your targets | Free tier | Cheapest year | Who makes it |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| MacroFactor | Decides, and keeps decidingRe-estimated every week from your weight trend and what you logged. | NoNone. A 7-day trial, then it stops. | $71.99 | Stronger By Science Technologies, owned by its five founders |
| Carbon | Decides, and keeps decidingAdjusted at weekly check-ins against your results — "a slow week leads to an adjustment, not a restart". | NoNone, and no trial advertised. | $99.99 | Co-founded by Layne Norton, PhD, and Keith Kraker, RD |
| MyFitnessPal | Decides onceCalculated once from your details, then left alone until you change it. | YesYes, with ads. Logging included, barcode scanning not. | $79.99 | MyFitnessPal, Inc., owned by Francisco Partners since October 2020 |
| Lose It! | Decides onceA calorie budget set at signup. Macros are secondary to the calorie number. | YesYes. Reports suggest barcode scanning has moved behind Premium for newer accounts. | Not publishedSee below | FitNow, Inc. |
| Cronometer | Leaves it to youYou set them. It will not adjust them for you, and does not pretend to. | YesYes, and the most generous here: barcode scanning, custom targets and 82 micronutrients are all free. | $59.99 | Cronometer Software Inc., independent, founded 2005 in British Columbia |
| MacrosFirst | Leaves it to youYou set the grams, or use its calculator to start. It works portions back from the goal. | YesYes, described as fully functional. Barcode and label scanning included. | Not publishedSee below | Not stated anywhere on its own site |
Paid annually the spread is narrower than the marketing suggests: $59.99 at the cheapest end against $99.99 at the dearest, for software that does substantially the same logging. Both of the apps with no free tier sell a half-year as a hedge against committing to the whole one: MacroFactor at $47.99 and Carbon at $59.99.
The real decision is not between prices, though. It is between paying anything at all and 4 of these 6 having a free tier you could stay on indefinitely — MyFitnessPal, Lose It!, Cronometer, MacrosFirst. Cronometer's is the one worth singling out: barcode scanning and custom targets are both free there, and both sit behind MyFitnessPal's paywall.
Lose It! and MacrosFirst are missing from the table above on purpose.
Every other figure on this page was read off the publisher's own pages on the date in the table. These two could not be, so they are named as unknown rather than filled in from a review site. A price that is confidently wrong is worse than a gap, and it is the one fact you can check in thirty seconds for yourself.
Whichever you choose, the targets stay inside it. MyFitnessPal's partner API is closed to new applicants, MacroFactor and Carbon have none, and the Apple Health and Health Connect route carries what you ate, not what you were aiming at. So the honest answer to "can this site read my tracker" is no, and not because of a missing feature.
Which is why this one asks you to type four numbers. Paste them from whichever app you picked and the catalog resizes to them — the meals, the week and the shopping list. Already decided between the two most people arrive from? MacroFactor against MyFitnessPal in detail.
Checked 14 October 2026. Prices and paywalls move; this page is re-checked rather than rewritten, because every figure on it lives in one file with the date beside it.
Whichever app you pick, it stops at the number. These are the quickest plates in the catalog, weighed to whatever you paste in.

65g protein
510 kcal10 min

64g protein
540 kcal25 min

60g protein
520 kcal10 min

53g protein
490 kcal15 min

52g protein
445 kcal15 min

52g protein
421 kcal15 min
Serving suggestion — a photo of this kind of dish, not of this recipe.